What Is Perfectionism? 15 Warning Signs and Mental Health Effects

Perfectionism is a personality trait marked by an unyielding drive for flawlessness and exceptionally high standards. Perfectionists often push themselves to excel in every aspect of life, frequently setting unrealistic goals driven by a deep need to appear, feel, and be perceived as perfect.

What Is Perfectionism?

In psychology, perfectionism is an innate personality trait marked by an extreme pursuit of perfection and flawlessness. While it is considered a positive attribute ¹, it is often considered a maladaptive coping mechanism.

Negative perfectionism is commonly accompanied by critical self-evaluation, competitiveness, rigorous organization, as well as sensitivity to criticism and others’ evaluations.

Perfectionism is not a psychological disorder in itself and does not have a diagnostic criterion. However, increased levels of perfectionism have been linked to mental health issues, such as anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) ².

Studies ³ affirm that men often experience higher levels of perfectionist traits, in comparison to women. The latter, on the other hand, is associated with an increased ability to cope with this type of personality style.

Read More About Personality Here

Psychology Behind Perfectionism

Perfectionists are driven by a constant, often overwhelming urge to be flawless at all times. They frequently tie their self-worth to achievement and productivity, and they tend to hold themselves to unrealistic expectations and excessively high standards.

They pressure ⁴ themselves into achieving these extremely ambitious goals and this strains their mental and physical well-being. They also display character traits ⁵ associated with narcissism, neuroticism, self-criticality, and imposter syndrome.

Read More About Imposter Syndrome Here

Case Example

Case Study: Maladaptive Perfectionism in a College Student

Background
Bonnie recently enrolled at a prestigious academic institution to pursue a degree in Economics. Throughout her life, she has been exceptionally disciplined, highly competitive, and an overachiever who consistently upheld extremely high standards. Entering college, she remained determined to maintain these same values.

However, over time, her perfectionistic tendencies began to interfere with her well-being. She became increasingly intolerant of criticism, excessively self-critical, and obsessively competitive. Simple tasks started to consume an inordinate amount of time, as she fixated on completing everything to perfection. Managing her already packed schedule became another source of stress.

Bonnie’s unrealistic standards and compulsive work habits left little room for rest or recreation. She distanced herself from friends and family and avoided forming new relationships. Her rigid thinking not only imposed impossible expectations on herself but also extended to others around her. These expectations were rarely met, often resulting in disappointment and emotional distress.

Case Analysis
Bonnie’s experience clearly reflects the hallmarks of a perfectionist mindset. Her inflexible pursuit of excellence has made her overly controlling and preoccupied with every aspect of her life. Her behaviors indicate elevated levels of self-criticism, competitiveness, procrastination, and defensiveness.

As a result, Bonnie frequently experiences anxiety and struggles with everyday functioning. These symptoms suggest that she is not simply a high achiever but is dealing with maladaptive perfectionism—a form of perfectionism that negatively impacts psychological health and daily performance.

Signs Of Perfectionism

The common ⁶ signs/symptoms of perfectionism include:

An obsessive desire to act perfectly all the time
Rigid thinking and obsessiveness with rules and regulations
Experiencing intense anxiety over the simplest of tasks
Taking excessive time to complete tasks
Persistently setting lofty goals and unrealistic standards
Focusing on the end results and ignoring the process of growing and striving
Procrastination
Over-competitive tendencies
Excessive narcissistic but assurance-seeking behavior
Excessive fear of failure
High scores of self-criticality
Extreme defensiveness to criticism
An obsessive desire to control personal and professional relationships
Struggling to relax and communicate openly
Developing tendencies like workaholism and substance addiction

Perfectionism And Anxiety

Anxiety is a common byproduct of perfectionism. Since perfectionists often base their self-worth on their performance, they tend to feel constant pressure and anxiety when faced with tasks that may not meet their exceptionally high standards.

The doubt and helplessness that accompany performance anxiety due to perfectionism deplete cognitive and emotional resources in perfectionists. In fact, anxiety sensitivity and perfectionism ⁷ have common correlations in:

Preoccupation with flaws, mistakes, and failures
Obsession over personal standards
Sensitivity to criticism
High scores of self-doubt and self-inadequacy

Read More About Anxiety Here

Types Of Perfectionism

Studies categorize the common types ⁸ of perfectionist traits into the three following categories:

1. Socially prescribed perfectionists

Socially prescribed perfectionists are highly attuned to societal expectations, believing that their self-worth is contingent upon meeting external standards and appearing perfect in the eyes of others.

2. Other-oriented perfectionists

Other-oriented perfectionists impose high expectations and standards on others, often judging their worth based on how well they meet these ideals. They tend to be highly critical of those who fall short, which can strain relationships and create interpersonal tension.

3. Self-oriented perfectionists

Self-oriented perfectionists set high standards and expectations for themselves. Among the different types, high self-oriented perfectionism is often seen as the most adaptive, commonly linked to greater productivity, success, resourcefulness, assertiveness, and healthier emotional functioning.

Healthy Vs Unhealthy Perfectionism

Healthy or intrinsic perfectionism involves the pursuit of high—but realistic—standards and a strong commitment to quality. Individuals with this form of perfectionism are typically highly motivated, resourceful, and possess a strong work ethic along with effective social skills. Often displaying self-oriented perfectionism, they tend to achieve high levels of productivity and success while maintaining emotional balance.

Unhealthy ⁹ or extrinsic perfectionism is often marked by the traits inherent in socially prescribed or other-oriented perfectionists. They are driven by chronic fears of failure and rejection. Their perfectionism often leads to low self-esteem, stress, broken relationships, and low quality of life.

Read More About Self-esteem Here

What Causes Perfectionism?

Research ¹⁰ attributes the root causes of perfectionism to a combination of inborn tendencies and environmental factors, including:

In-born personality trait
A history of childhood abuse and trauma
Parental abuse, neglect, and abandonment
Growing up with a perfectionist and frequently disapproving parent
Feelings of low self-esteem and inadequacy
Fear of social rejection and criticism
Unhealthy patterns of attachment
A history of mental health conditions like obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), stress disorders, etc.

Perfectionism In Children And Adults

Research reveals that, in recent years, children, adolescents, and young adults ¹¹ have been developing a great number of perfectionist personalities. In children and adolescents, perfectionism manifests as a fear of failure, overcompetitiveness, low self-esteem, and emotional disorders ¹².

Perfectionists often fall into two extremes—they either overwork themselves to exhaustion or withdraw even from the simplest tasks out of fear of failure. In children, perfectionist behaviors commonly include a reluctance to try new things, preferring familiar experiences and avoiding new sports or extracurricular activities.

In adults, perfectionism often manifests as setting unrealistic goals and pursuing overly ambitious plans. These individuals are typically highly sensitive, self-aware, and competitive, often overthinking and striving for control in all areas of life. Their self-worth is deeply tied to their performance and ability to meet perfectionist standards. Driven by an intense fear of failure, they tend to overwork in an effort to prevent any perceived shortcomings.

Effects Of Perfectionism

Moderately regulated levels of perfectionism are good for our everyday functioning. However, too much of perfectionist tendencies are associated with ¹³:

Self-sabotage tendencies, such as procrastination and poor time management
Vulnerability to poor stress reactivity, burnout, and fatigue
Strained personal and professional relationships
Lower levels of life satisfaction
Risk of chronic mental health issues

Mental Health Impact Of Perfectionism

People with perfectionist traits often suffer from cognitive and emotional difficulties, behavioral problems, and conflicting views about ability, self, and the meaning of failure.

They also develop serious physical health symptoms ¹⁴ associated with cardiovascular diseases (CVD), coronary diseases, and mortality. High scores of this trait negatively impact daily functioning, professional dynamics, and social relationships.

Maladaptive perfectionists are also vulnerable to several mental health conditions ¹⁵ such as:

Chronically low self-esteem
Performance anxiety
Mood disorders like depression, bipolar depression, etc.
Anxiety, especially, social anxiety [Read more]
Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder (OCPD)
Paranoid personality disorder (PPD)
Narcissistic personality disorder (NPD)
Eating disorders [Read more]
Sleep disorders [Read more]
Stress disorders
Work addiction and burnout [Read more]
Substance use disorder, etc.

How Is Perfectionism Treated?

Perfectionism is a personality trait that can often be managed through self-reflection and healthy coping strategies. However, when perfectionistic tendencies become chronic and begin to interfere with daily functioning or mental well-being, it is advisable to seek professional support or medical intervention.

In recent years, cognitive-behavioral therapy ¹⁶ has gained grounds for addressing the signs of perfectionism. It helps perfectionists to challenge their negative belief systems and thoughts. It helps them to reflect on and reorient their perfectionist tendencies and be more accepting of flaws and errors.

The therapeutic sessions are aimed to enhance the desire to lead a conscious and meaningful life. It also helps them develop effective self-help strategies to handle emergency situations. Other interventions ¹⁷ for perfectionism include:

Psychodynamic/interpersonal therapy (PI)
Exposure and response prevention (ERP)
Acceptance-based behavior therapy (ABBT)

How To Overcome Perfectionism

Consider the following measures ¹⁸ for overcoming perfectionism:

Create an environment, at work or at home, where you feel safe and comfortable.
Consider following a well-balanced eat-sleep-work schedule to care for both your mental and physical health.
Understand that flaws, errors, and failures are common parts of life.
Stop equating errors or drawbacks with personal defectiveness. Engage in positive self-talk.
Use constructive coping skills when dealing with disappointments.
Recognize and accept that not everyone will share your personal high standards.
Become aware of your tendencies and try to alter them. Examine your competitiveness and, when necessary, decrease your emphasis on winning every time.
Identify your strengths and weaknesses. Work to better the positive attributes and challenge the negative ones.
Celebrate the victory of “baby steps” when it comes to changing your maladaptive perfectionist approaches to task management.
Avail mindfulness and relaxation techniques to help yourself relax.
If necessary, avail therapy.

Takeaway

While perfectionism is often socially admired, it can become detrimental when the need to be perfect turns into an obsession. A healthy degree of perfectionism can be motivating, but when it becomes excessive, it must be addressed. If left unchecked, it may escalate into serious mental health conditions such as Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD), significantly affecting one’s quality of life and relationships.

At A Glance

Perfectionism is a personality trait marked by the drive to achieve flawlessness.
It is not classified as a diagnosable mental health disorder.
There are three types of perfectionism: self-oriented, socially prescribed, and other-oriented.
Common causes include parental perfectionism, childhood abuse, and fear of social rejection.
Self-help tips include practicing self-reflection and building healthy coping strategies.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Do perfectionists have higher IQs?

Research frequently links perfectionists with higher IQs and cautious personalities.

2. Is perfectionism a mental disorder?

Perfectionism is a personality trait and not a psychological disorder in itself. However, increased levels of perfectionism have been linked to mental health issues, such as anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

3. What personality disorder is perfectionism?

Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder (OCPD) is a personality disorder characterized by extreme perfectionism, order, and neatness.

4. What do perfectionists struggle with?

Most perfectionists struggle with mental health conditions like anxiety, depression, lower life satisfaction, and low self-worth.

5. Is being a perfectionist a good thing?

Moderate levels of perfectionism have their benefits. However, being too much of a perfectionist is not a good thing. This personality trait is linked to burnout, depression, anxiety, and mortality.

6. Are you a perfectionist?

If you tend to accomplish each task perfectly all the time and feel intensely afraid of being judged by others, then you may be a perfectionist.

Perfectionism

Table of Contents

What Is Perfectionism?