Surprising Result: Ketamine No More Effective Than Placebo in Treating Depression




Intravenous ketamine, administered during surgical anesthesia, has shown no significant advantage over a placebo in reducing the severity of depression among patients with major depressive disorder.

The research, led by Dr. Theresa R. Lii from the Stanford University School of Medicine in California, focused on a group of 40 adult patients diagnosed with major depressive disorder, all scheduled for routine surgery.

These individuals were randomly divided into two groups, with one receiving a single infusion of ketamine during their usual anesthesia, while the other received a placebo.

The primary outcome measure was the assessment of depression severity, quantified using the Montgomery-Åsberg Depression Rating Scale. The evaluations took place at one, two, and three days after the infusion. After all follow-up visits, participants were asked to guess which intervention they had received.

The study’s findings failed to provide any evidence of significant differences in the primary outcome when analyzed using a mixed-effects model (-5.82; 95 percent confidence interval, -13.3 to 1.64; P = 0.13). Approximately 36.8 percent of participants correctly guessed their treatment assignments, with similar proportions in both the ketamine and placebo groups.

Analyzing Sedentary Behavior and Dementia Risk

In a separate endeavor, researchers delved into the realm of sedentary behavior and its potential impact on dementia risk. This study drew from a vast dataset of accelerometer readings, in which over 100,000 adults agreed to wear wrist-worn accelerometers that tracked their movement around the clock for one week.

This initiative was part of a U.K. Biobank sub-study. The researchers zeroed in on a sample of approximately 50,000 adults aged 60 and older who, at the study’s outset, had no dementia diagnosis.

Sophisticated machine-learning algorithms were applied to the extensive dataset, enabling the classification of behaviors based on various levels of physical activity.

These algorithms successfully distinguished between different activities, such as sedentary behavior versus sleeping. Crucially, the researchers scrutinized the amount of time individuals spent engaged in various sedentary behaviors.

After a follow-up period averaging six years, the research team identified 414 cases of dementia using inpatient hospital records and death registry data. Statistical analyses were conducted, adjusting for demographics, lifestyle characteristics, and chronic conditions that could influence brain health, such as heart disease or diabetes.

The study’s findings revealed a significant increase in dementia risk for individuals who spent more than 10 hours a day engaged in sedentary activities, regardless of how that time accumulated. However, sedentary behaviors totaling around 10 hours or less exhibited no elevated risk of dementia.

This discovery offers a sense of reassurance, particularly for those in office jobs that necessitate prolonged periods of sitting. Nevertheless, individuals may still reduce their risk of dementia by making efforts to limit their daily sedentary time as much as possible.

The research surrounding the effectiveness of ketamine in treating depression highlights the complexity of this mental health condition. While ketamine has shown promise in some cases, this study emphasizes that it may not be universally effective for all individuals with major depressive disorder.

As research in the field of mental health continues to advance, the search for more personalized and effective treatments remains a priority.

The study on sedentary behavior and dementia risk underscores the importance of maintaining an active lifestyle, even as individuals age. Prolonged periods of sedentary behavior, beyond 10 hours a day, were associated with a significantly higher risk of developing dementia.

This knowledge reinforces the importance of encouraging physical activity and reducing sedentary time for overall brain health.

These two studies offer valuable insights into mental health and brain function. The ketamine study reminds us that treatment for depression remains a complex puzzle, and personalized approaches may be necessary.

Meanwhile, the research on sedentary behavior and dementia underscores the critical role of physical activity in promoting cognitive well-being.

As the scientific community delves deeper into these areas, the quest for effective treatments and lifestyle adjustments continues, with the ultimate goal of enhancing mental health and preserving cognitive function.

— Share —

Up Next

Aviation Industry Gathers to Address Mental Health Challenges for Pilots and Crew

Aviation Industry and Mental Health

A significant event occurred recently, where professionals in the aviation industry converged to discuss the critical obstacles to accessing mental health care in this sector.

The meeting was triggered by an alarming incident of an off-duty pilot trying to sabotage a commercial flight in October thus, emphasizing the need for supportive and accessible mental health support system for pilots and crews.

Jennifer Homendy, Chairwoman of National Transportation Safety Board, pointed out a prevailing culture that leaves aviation professionals with no choice but lie or keep quiet when they are in need of assistance,

Up Next

Renowned UK Figures Urge Halt to Antidepressant Prescriptions for Mild Conditions, Call for Holistic Mental Health Approach

Use of Antidepressant

Prominent figures in health and politics in the United Kingdom have come together to form a coalition.

This has very forcefully called for an immediate end to doctors prescribing new antidepressants for people with mild symptoms of mental disorders.

This fervent request spearheaded by highly acclaimed psychiatrists, distinguished psychologists, and respected politicians carries with it an intense sense of urgency.

The urgency aimed at stemming the trend towards increased num

Up Next

Allina Health’s Closure of Adolescent Mental Health Unit Sparks Concerns and Regulatory Scrutiny in Minnesota

Allina Health Care

Unfortunately, Allina Health shut down the mental health unit for teenagers at United Hospital in St. Paul leaving parents of mentally ill children furious and raising alarm among the nursing fraternity, mental health advocates and officials in the state of Minnesota.

By September this year, the operations had been moved to Abbott Northwestern Hospital in Minneapolis leaving families like Susan’s with limited choices and increasing difficulties in accessing life-saving services for their vulnerable juveniles.

Up Next

South Korea Unveils Ambitious Mental Health Initiative to Tackle Rising Suicide Rates

South Korea and Mental Health

South Korea has taken an unprecedented step of putting in place an all-inclusive strategy to deal with its persistently high suicide rates, particularly among young people.

This move, announced by President Yoon Suk Yeol, is part of the government’s efforts to prioritize mental health and enact preventive strategies that work.

South Korea has consistently topped the OECD countries’ list of suicide rates for about 20 years now, a fact emphasized by the shocking figure of 25.2 deaths per 100,000 people in year 2022- more than twice as the OECD average.


Up Next

Study Reveals: Eating Fatty Foods Under Stress Harms Brain and Heart Function

Stress and Fatty Food

A shocking connection between stress, high-fat consumption and their adverse effects on cardiovascular and brain health has been discovered in a groundbreaking study conducted at the University of Birmingham.

The research was carried out by Rosalind Baynham and her colleagues who sought to determine the repercussions of consuming fatty food in persons subjected to stressful conditions.

Experiment: Stress and Fatty Food Consumption

Up Next

Crisis in Maternal Mental Health Care Uncovered: Thousands of Women Denied Support in the UK

Maternal Mental Health Crisis

Almost 20,000 women suffering from maternal mental health problems as a result of pregnancies or births are not being offered essential care, causing the NHS to be put under scrutiny.

However, some regions of England have seen waits for treatment exceeding 19 months due to excessive demand on consultant services where such women go to for help.

This disturbing scenario has caused anger, with experts describing it as “an absolute scandal,” and raises concerns that shortage and delay in essential care may isolate vulnerable mothers and lead to life-long health consequences for both them and their children.

Up Next

Unveiling ‘Money Dysmorphia’: The Psychological Struggle Affecting Financial Well-being

Money Dysmorphia

A recent study of financial health has revealed an interesting psychological problem named “money dysmorphia” which shares many similarities with clinical body dysmorphia.

It is a concept that has not yet received formal recognition by the medical community, and it is about a person’s abnormal perception of their financial condition that leads to wrong choices on money and raises broader mental issues.

Ali Katz, a renowned estate attorney and founder of the Family Wealth Planning Institute, addressed this intriguing discovery.